Hello everyone, I’m Doctor Mi
Today I would like to recommend to you a very objective, conscientious and rigorous medical self-media – Dr. Lilac.
They have always followed the principles and attitudes of science, delivering content with knowledge, warmth and attitude to the Chinese people.
Except… >
and posted a video on November 11, 2018.
In the video , they said that crab and persimmon cannot be eaten together. It is because “The Brief Introduction of the Golden Chamber” says thatpersimmons and crabs are both fire, and fire and fire are mutually restrained. However, in the research paper of the Republic of China in 1935 and the research of Lanzhou University and Harbin University in 2006, the experiment of eating crabs and persimmons was carried out, which proved that this is completely absurd.
The question is… what the hell does fire and fire overcome? In traditional Chinese medicine, there is no such saying that fire and fire overcome each other.
And “The Golden Chamber Never Said ” Can crab and persimmon be eaten together? Shooting targets in such a void is more or less suspected of bullying the medical saint Zhang Zhongjing, who has been dead for thousands of years and cannot argue with them in person.
Secondly, in the two papers they mentioned, there was no The experiment of eating persimmons and crabs was carried out.
Dr. Clove may not understand traditional Chinese medicine, but when popularizing western medicine, don’t even take a look at his own papers ?
As for the end of their video, the so-called self-testing is even more ridiculous. Putting aside the dose and talking about toxicity is a hooligan. As doctors, they should understand that everyone’s physique is different. Just like most people in China are lactose intolerant, can we find one lactose intolerant among these 1.4 billion people to prove that all Chinese are lactose intolerant?
Such popular science, I really don’t know if it’s refuting rumors or spreading rumors.
Secondly, they also believe that brown sugar, red dates and donkey-hide gelatin do not replenish blood. The reason is also very simple, the iron content is not high.
width=”600
span> Sounds reasonable right? But the problem is that if high iron content is equal to blood, why have we never seen Western medicine make ischemic patients lick with iron pots?
This is not because the production of blood is a complex process. After entering the human body, iron in food needs to be absorbed and transformed before it can be used. of. Just like brown sugar, although most of it is sugar, the large amount of vitamins it contains are very conducive to the absorption of iron, which is also iron supplementation.
And and more importantly, qi and blood in traditional Chinese medicine and medical Blood is not the same, it is a complex concept that includes essence, qi, and god. Many patients with weak qi and blood in traditional Chinese medicine may have no problem if they verify the normalization of blood routine.
Talking about brown sugar blood supplementation as blood supplementation is like describing a hippocampus as a horse and soy sauce as oil. It is confusing concepts and confounding right and wrong.
So if Clove really wants to criticize Chinese medicine, it is best to put ” The Yellow Emperor’s Classic of Internal Medicine, The Brief Introduction of the Golden Chamber, and Treatise on Febrile Diseases and Miscellaneous Diseases should be read once before speaking.
p>
Secondly, medical science should be rigorous. Because this is medical science, once something goes wrong, no one knows what will happen!
However, Clove is a rigorous and objective medical self-media. It is understandable to make mistakes if you don’t understand Chinese medicine. But this does not mean that they will not make mistakes.
For example, they mentioned several times that eating garlic cannot prevent cancer. And they brought out the so-called experimental evidence.
But in fact, there have been multiple research results that prove that garlic can really inhibit cancer…
I have never seen Lilac explain this. Their so-called refutation of rumors is for popular science, or the headline party to attract traffic.
But I still believe that Clove is a rigorous and objective medical self-media.
Although he sometimes slaps himself in the face.
For example, he said more than once that skipping breakfast is not the reason for gallstones
< img class="content_title" height="300" layout="responsive" sizes="(min-width: 320px) 320px, 100vw" src="https://mmbiz.qpic.cn/mmbiz_png/X0F9HHk8ZGC9ZiaZiaZ9k2ic1KX7bjSFlqMJcekE1UUkVRydGDnatticIbD1ibqA4UmicbiawYMAsXomlgw" widthDSUOGwYMAsXomlgw" ="600">
More than once, skipping breakfast is the reason for gallstones.
It makes people wonder, should I eat this breakfast or not?
Am I listening to lilac? Or not? I quickly realized that this wasn’t an issue because I was both for and against Dr. Clove whether I had breakfast or not.
Win-win, win!
But these are all minor problems. The most unacceptable thing is that cloves are still fighting the epidemic. Things are yin and yang weird.
February 4, 2020At a critical moment in the fight against the epidemic, Director Liu of the Sichuan Provincial People’s Hospital, for everyone to popularize the fecal-oral spread of the new crown, was ridiculed by Lilac out of context on Weibo.
After excretion of digestive tract pathogens through feces, fecal-oral transmission is Because the feces directly contaminate the food, or contaminate the hands, and then indirectly contaminate the food, it enters the body through the digestive tract, causing the process of infection.
Director Liu said this just in a way that everyone can understand, emphasizing the importance of washing hands frequently.
I really don’t understand, what’s so sarcastic about this? Everyone is Chinese, will actively fighting the epidemic hinder the interests of cloves?
However, I have said so much, and I did not mention the mistakes of cloves due to space limitations, but I still hope that everyone understands that no one is perfect, and no gold is perfect.
Except for the minor faults, such as deliberately smearing traditional Chinese medicine, making rumors, nonsense thesis materials, popular science breakfast for schizophrenia, and yin-yang new crown anti-epidemic experts, Dr. Lilac is still a worthwhile one. Everyone trusts a very objective, conscientious and rigorous medical self-media.
Recommended reading”If you keep this medicine at home in spring, can you cure two-thirds of urticaria and inedia? Fasting? Is your body ready? Please transfer to the people of Shanghai Lianhua Qingwen, Huoxiang upright. . How are the proprietary Chinese medicines issued by the community used? (With tongue photo for favorite)“Today’s live broadcast preview”